🎀 FREE SHIPPING ON U.S. ORDERS $100+ 🎀
allymakesmagic™
Explore collections:
  • AMM X BRIEANNE
  • AMSTERDAM, NL
  • ARLINGTON, TX
  • ATLANTA, GA
  • BESTSELLERS
  • BLANKETS

Recommended products

View all
  • "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap
    "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap
    "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap

    "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap

    $27.13

  • '89 floral *clear* sticker '89 floral *clear* sticker
    '89 floral *clear* sticker '89 floral *clear* sticker

    '89 floral *clear* sticker

    $4.99

  • '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery) '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)
    '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery) '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)

    '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)

    $42.13

    S / Ash
  • '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers

    '89 subway tile stickers

    From $3.99

  • 'MOOrica crop tee 'MOOrica crop tee
    'MOOrica crop tee 'MOOrica crop tee

    'MOOrica crop tee

    $29.13

    Ivory / S
  • 'MOOrica tee 'MOOrica tee
    'MOOrica tee 'MOOrica tee

    'MOOrica tee

    $27.93

    Light Blue / XS Vintage White / XS
  • HOME
  • NEW!
  • SHOP
    SHOP
    • 🦋 THE ERAS 🐍
      • eras tour merch
      • all eras
    • THE FANDOMS
    • SEASONAL
    • SHOP BY CATEGORY
      • apparel
      • stickers
      • coasters
      • stationery
      • calendars
      • etc!
    • SHOP ALL!
  • SALE
    SALE
    • sample sale
    • shop all sale
  • FAQ
    FAQ
    • faq
    • size charts
    • get in touch
    • charitable magic
    • collab w/us
  • HOME
  • NEW!
  • SHOP
    • 🦋 THE ERAS 🐍
      • eras tour merch
      • all eras
    • THE FANDOMS
    • SEASONAL
    • SHOP BY CATEGORY
      • apparel
      • stickers
      • coasters
      • stationery
      • calendars
      • etc!
    • SHOP ALL!
  • SALE
    • sample sale
    • shop all sale
  • FAQ
    • faq
    • size charts
    • get in touch
    • charitable magic
    • collab w/us
Explore collections:
  • AMM X BRIEANNE
  • AMSTERDAM, NL
  • ARLINGTON, TX
  • ATLANTA, GA
  • BESTSELLERS
  • BLANKETS

Recommended products

View all
  • "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap
    "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap
    "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap

    "slut!" denim embroidered baseball cap

    $27.13

  • '89 floral *clear* sticker '89 floral *clear* sticker
    '89 floral *clear* sticker '89 floral *clear* sticker

    '89 floral *clear* sticker

    $4.99

  • '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery) '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)
    '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery) '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)

    '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)

    $42.13

    S / Ash
  • '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers

    '89 subway tile stickers

    From $3.99

  • 'MOOrica crop tee 'MOOrica crop tee
    'MOOrica crop tee 'MOOrica crop tee

    'MOOrica crop tee

    $29.13

    Ivory / S
  • 'MOOrica tee 'MOOrica tee
    'MOOrica tee 'MOOrica tee

    'MOOrica tee

    $27.93

    Light Blue / XS Vintage White / XS
Bag 0
  • Home
  • VARSITY COLLECTION
Sort by
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
  • collegiate stickers collegiate stickers
    collegiate stickers collegiate stickers

    collegiate stickers

    $3.99

  • '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers
    '89 subway tile stickers '89 subway tile stickers

    '89 subway tile stickers

    From $3.99

  • eras tour '23/'24 sticker eras tour '23/'24 sticker
    eras tour '23/'24 sticker eras tour '23/'24 sticker

    eras tour '23/'24 sticker

    $3.99

  • '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery) '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)
    '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery) '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)

    '89 seagull sweater (faux embroidery)

    $42.13

    S / Ash
  • welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater
    welcome to ny varsity sweater welcome to ny varsity sweater

    welcome to ny varsity sweater

    $32.13

    S / Dark Heather S / Light Blue S / Light Pink S / Sand S / Sport Grey
  • homebody sticker homebody sticker
    homebody sticker homebody sticker

    homebody sticker

    $3.99

  • chilton prep tee chilton prep tee
    chilton prep tee chilton prep tee

    chilton prep tee

    $32.13

    Sport Grey / S
  • indoorsy sticker indoorsy sticker
    indoorsy sticker indoorsy sticker

    indoorsy sticker

    $3.99

  • chilton prep sweater chilton prep sweater
    chilton prep sweater chilton prep sweater

    chilton prep sweater

    $37.79

    S / Sport Grey
  • introvert sticker introvert sticker
    introvert sticker introvert sticker

    introvert sticker

    $3.99

  • ceo sticker ceo sticker
    ceo sticker ceo sticker

    ceo sticker

    $3.99

  • dramatic sticker dramatic sticker
    dramatic sticker dramatic sticker

    dramatic sticker

    $3.99

  • welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee
    welcome to ny varsity tee welcome to ny varsity tee

    welcome to ny varsity tee

    $32.79

    Blue Jean / S Blue Spruce / S Chambray / S Pepper / S
  • self made sticker self made sticker
    self made sticker self made sticker

    self made sticker

    $3.99

  • offline sticker offline sticker
    offline sticker offline sticker

    offline sticker

    $3.99

  • summer of '45 tee summer of '45 tee
    summer of '45 tee summer of '45 tee

    summer of '45 tee

    $32.79

    Chambray / S Seafoam / S Graphite / S Grey / S Khaki / S Light Green / S Pepper / S Terracotta / S True Navy / S Violet / S Washed Denim / S Watermelon / S
  • nyc sweater (faux embroidery) nyc sweater (faux embroidery)
    nyc sweater (faux embroidery) nyc sweater (faux embroidery)

    nyc sweater (faux embroidery)

    $37.79

    S / Ash
  • constance-billard hoodie constance-billard hoodie
    constance-billard hoodie constance-billard hoodie

    constance-billard hoodie

    $55.13

    True Navy / S

FAN-MADE

we're fan-girls first. each design is dreamt from our love of pop-culture with the tiniest details only the truly obsessed will understand.

GIVING BACK

it's giving... putting our money where our mouth is! we happily donate portions of every sale to the relevant charities! see more here

SIZE INCLUSIVE

no upcharges, no exceptions! we’re all about making sure every size gets the same cute & cozy treatment—because that’s just how it should be.

SMALL BIZ, BIG DREAMS

owned/operated by women & built on equality. as a small business, we stand for inclusivity and fairness in everything we do.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
©2025 ALLYMAKESMAGIC™

Your cart

Spend $100.00 more to get free shipping. Congrats, You're eligible for free shipping!

Your cart is empty